Rookie Class Review: How the Cowboys and Bears Stack Up
Every week, I dive into the rookie classes of the Dallas Cowboys and Chicago Bears, analyzing their performances and comparing how they measure up against each other. This week, I’ll break down the grades for each player, courtesy of PFF.com.
First Round: Booker
Booker faces a tough test this week, as he’ll need to communicate effectively with Brock Hoffman to pass off twists and keep the pocket square. If he can win first contact and keep the pocket intact, the Cowboys can thrive in second-and-manageable situations. I’ll take a deeper dive into Booker’s challenges later this week on “Reading Between the Lines.” Grade: 53.0
Second Round: Ezeiruaku
Ezeiruaku has had a quiet start to the season, but this week sets up as a potential breakout game. The Bears’ offense has struggled with protection, and Ezeiruaku’s speed and inside-counter rush could be the perfect antidote. If he can keep his rush lanes tight and force Caleb Williams to climb into traffic, he could notch his first sack. Grade: 72.9
Third Round: Inactive
This player is currently on the non-football injury list, so we’ll have to wait and see when he’ll be back in action.
Fifth Round: James
James remains inactive, and it’s unclear when he’ll see the field. With Miles Sanders and Javonte Williams producing, Brian Schottenheimer may stick with what’s working, leaving James on the sidelines. Grade: N/A
Sixth Round: Inactive
This player is also inactive, and we’ll have to wait for further updates on his status. Grade: N/A
Seventh Round: Toia
Toia has been easing into the rotation, but this week’s matchup against the Bears could be a turning point. If he can win half a yard on first down and dent the pocket, the Cowboys can limit the Bears’ offense. Grade: 30.2
Seventh Round: Inactive
Another inactive player, we’ll have to wait and see when he’ll be ready to contribute. Grade: N/A
First Round: Loveland
Loveland has seen modest usage so far, but his role is expected to expand as the Bears’ offense improves. With plus movement skills and a strong catch-point timing, Loveland projects as a classic in-line or slot-flex tight end. Grade: 48.7
Second Round: Burden
Burden has been quiet in his first two games, but his dynamic skills as a slot receiver and running-back balance after the catch make him an exciting prospect. Expect gradual growth in manufactured touches as the Bears stabilize their offense. Grade: 46.7
Second Round: Turner
Turner’s inactivity is a head-scratcher, given the Bears’ defensive line struggles. The second-round pick out of Texas A&M has yet to play a snap, despite being a healthy scratch. Will he finally see the field this week? Grade: N/A
Second Round: Trapilo
Trapilo’s inactivity is another mystery, given the Bears’ offensive line woes. Despite being taken in the second round, Trapilo has been inactive since the season started. Grade: N/A
Third Round: Muhammad
Muhammad has had a light but positive start, logging rotational and special-teams snaps. With four total tackles and no splash plays, he’s looking to stop runs inside and run to the football when on the field. Grade: 73.9
Seventh Round: Vaughn
Vaughn has had a limited but encouraging start, with one catch for 11 yards in Week 1 and seven rushes for 28 yards in Week 2. His role as a change-of-pace back could grow, but he’ll need to find ways to contribute in a limited offense. Grade: 53.4
Overall, both the Cowboys and Bears have rookies with immense potential, but it’s clear that some are being utilized more effectively than others. As the season progresses, it’ll be interesting to see how these players develop and contribute to their respective teams.
